nloginov's personal space

Should You Actually Use AV1 for recording Gaming Clips?

There's a new trend in the PC tech sphere: AV1 encoding. Both NVIDIA and AMD now support it on their latest graphics cards. But is it actually worth the hype? And more importantly… should you use it? That's what we're breaking down today.

What is AV1?

AV1 is a new, super-efficient video codec. Its big selling point is low bitrate performance. Here's what that means in practice: imagine you record a clip. With H.264, you might need 50 megabits per second for it to look clean and sharp. With AV1, you could get that same visual quality at just 20 megabits per second.

AV1 Comparison with H264

Record at a fraction of the bitrate, and your footage will still look cleaner compared to H.264 or even HEVC and take less size on the hard drive.

Sounds perfect, right? Well… not so fast.

The Bitrate Comparison

Here's a simple comparison showing how much bitrate each codec needs for the same quality:

H.264:  ██████████████████████████████████████████████████  50 Mbps
HEVC:   ███████████████████████████████████                 35 Mbps
AV1:    ████████████████████                                20 Mbps
    

Lower is better - AV1 achieves the same quality at significantly lower bitrates

AV1 Performing Very Well At Low Bitrate

The Huge Downside: Compatibility

Because AV1 has one huge downside: compatibility. Or really, the lack of it.

It's so new that most phones, many media players, and even some editing apps don't recognize it yet.

So imagine this: you record an awesome gaming clip in AV1. The file is tiny, the quality looks crisp. You send it to a friend on Discord. They tap it on their iPhone… and nothing happens. It just won't play.

AV1 Video Does Not Play on iPhone

Or you import it into Adobe Premiere… and you get an error: "file format not supported."

AV1 Cannot Be Imported Into Adobe Premiere Pro

Suddenly, that space-saving miracle clip is basically stuck on your hard drive.

AV1 Compatibility Status

✓ Works:

YouTube, newer Android phones (2022+), Windows 11, VLC Player, Chrome browser

✗ Doesn't work:

Most iPhones, Instagram, TikTok, many TVs, older media players, some editing software

AV1 Only Shines at Low Bitrates

AV1 On Low Bitrates

Here's another important point: AV1 only shines at low bitrates.

There is no point in using it if you already record at a high bitrate!

If you're recording at high bitrates anyway — say, 50 Mbps or more — H.264 and HEVC already look fantastic. AV1 won't magically look better here. You'll just be using more encoding power for zero visual gain.

The Performance Impact

And about that encoding power — this is actually important for performance.

AV1 is extremely demanding to encode. If your GPU doesn't have dedicated AV1 hardware encoding (think RTX 40-series or RX 7000 and up), and you try to encode it using your CPU…

Your game will stutter. Your frames will drop. It'll be a terrible experience.

Encoding Performance Impact (CPU Usage While Gaming)

H.264:  ████████                                            Low (10-15% CPU)
HEVC:   ████████████████                                    Medium (20-30% CPU)
AV1:    ████████████████████████████████████████████████    Very High (60-80% CPU)
    

Higher CPU usage = worse gaming performance. AV1 software encoding kills your FPS.

With Hardware Encoding (Modern GPUs)

H.264 (NVENC/VCE):  ██                                      Minimal impact
HEVC (NVENC/VCE):   ███                                     Minimal impact
AV1 (NVENC/VCE):    ███                                     Minimal impact
    

Hardware encoding fixes the problem - but you need RTX 40-series or RX 7000+ GPUs.

Where AV1 is a Game-Changer: Streaming

But there's one area where AV1 isn't just good — it's a game-changer.

Streaming.

AV1 For Streaming

If you stream to YouTube, AV1 is like super good. YouTube accepts it natively, and the efficiency is insane. You can stream at a much lower bitrate, and it will look better than H.264 — fewer compression artifacts, cleaner motion, better detail in shadows.

So if your internet upload speed isn't amazing, AV1 streaming can seriously elevate your quality.

Should You Use AV1?

Use AV1 if:

✓ You want smaller file sizes for recordings
✓ You stream to YouTube or another AV1-friendly platform
✓ You have a modern GPU that handles it in hardware (RTX 40-series, RX 7000+)
✓ You don't need wide compatibility

Avoid AV1 if:

✗ You share clips with friends or post on social media
✗ You edit in software that doesn't support it yet
✗ You play back on older phones, tablets, or TVs
✗ You already record at high bitrates

The Bottom Line

AV1 isn't here to replace H.264 or HEVC. It's another tool — incredibly powerful, but very situational.

If you know exactly why you're choosing it, AV1 is awesome. But if you just click it because it's new… you might end up with files you can't use.

So choose wisely.

AV1 Image